Saturday, April 1, 2023
HomeNewsPrivatize Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae

Privatize Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae

Published on

Mark Calabria, currently Vice President Mike Pence’s chief economist, is President Trump’s nominee to lead the Federal Housing Finance Agency. The FHFA is the chief regulator of mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the government-sponsored enterprises.

Calabria is a longtime advocate for ending government ownership of the GSEs. He further supports reforms that would greatly diminish the two firms’ dominance in the mortgage market. Such reforms are long overdue and would be a welcome sign for the stability of U.S. financial markets.

Click here to watch weekly episodes of our Housing Development Programme on AIT

The GSEs played an important role in fomenting the financial crisis. The mortgage market is not now characterized by the reckless underwriting practices that were dominant in the years leading up to the crisis. However, the GSEs are still severely undercapitalized and continue to play an outsized role in the mortgage market. The risk posed to taxpayers, and to economic stability, remain.

Proposals to remove the GSEs from the government’s balance sheet have enjoyed support from both parties. Yet, no action has been taken. One reason may be that the GSEs have been quite profitable in recent years. The terms of the conservatorship stipulate that profits are turned over to the Treasury. Thus far, the Treasury has reaped $286 billion in profits from the GSEs.

Politicians may also resist reform because the GSEs have served as vehicles for pushing policy objectives, while obscuring the costs to taxpayers. For example, the government pushed policies, such as affordable housing goals and the Community Reinvestment Act, which mandated that the GSEs expand high-risk borrowing.

In September of 2008, the FHFA, then only in its first few days of operation, placed the GSEs into conservatorship. This was seen as an emergency measure to prevent the housing market from going into a tailspin. It was meant to be a temporary measure, but to this day the U.S. Treasury has maintained a 79.9 percent ownership stake in the two corporations.

However, a sharp drop in house prices could result in widespread default. Prior to the crisis, regulators required the GSEs to hold economic capital, that is, liquid low-risk investments, to protect against large-scale default. Alas, the required levels were far too low. Under government conservatorship, the GSEs are only permitted to hold nominal capital reserves.

If the GSEs are too lax in the standards for loans that they back, instability cascades through the market. As the early 2000s demonstrated, mortgage originators often have little concern for borrower risk, provided the GSEs, or other backers, are willing to guarantee their loans.

The GSEs need to hold adequate capital was attenuated because of their implicit backing from the federal government. The strength of their government charter was reinforced by the reported $200 million spent on lobbying and campaign contributions over the decade preceding their collapse.

Because of their government backing, and the competitive advantage it afforded, they were able to grow far larger than otherwise. At the time of the crisis, they owned or guaranteed more than $5 trillion in mortgage debt, making them critical to the functioning of mortgage finance, or “Too Big to Fail.”

To reduce the risk to financial market and taxpayers alike, the government should allow the GSEs to recapitalize and then remove them from the government’s books. Fannie and Freddie’s government charters should be revoked. Both should be spun off into much smaller entities that do not pose systemic risk to the economy.

Source: Seth H. Giertz is an associate professor of economics and a Senior Research Fellow with the Colloquium for the Advancement of Free-Enterprise Education (CAFÉ), both at the University of Texas at Dallas.

Latest articles

US nominee Ajay Banga emerges sole candidate for World Bank top job

Ajay Banga, an Indian-American business leader, is set to head the World Bank after emerging as...

Experts, stakeholders set economic agenda for in-coming govt

The state of Nigeria’s economy has got many fearing for the worse due to...

Shareholders blame Aso Savings of breach of corporate governance rules, asset stripping inmanagement of Union Homes, Petitions SEC,FRCN and CAC

Key HighlightsShareholders have lodged a petition with the Securities & ExchangeCommission (SEC), Financial Reporting...

Debt trap and incoming administrations (2)

In 2020, one of the reputable national newspapers in Nigeria in its editorial comment...

More like this

The Affordable Housing Mirage

In all of the hand-wringing over the lack of “affordable housing” in not only...

BREAKING: Emefiele Begs NLC To Shelve Protest Over Naira Scarcity

The governor of Central Bank of Nigeria, Godwin Emefiele, on Monday appealed to the...

Danger looms in Lagos, 349 buildings in distress, Govt reveals

Danger looms in Lagos As part of the effort to check incessant building collapse...